Sugar Grove, PA Area Cold Cases

cold-case-record__McClellan

Name

Betty McClellan

Age

Cause of Death

Gunshot

Info

He was shot two times in the neck and jaw

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Allison

Name

Robert Allison

Age

42

Cause of Death

Missing

Info

Missing

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Lubbert

Name

Sandra Lubbert

Age

Cause of Death

Homicide

Info

Homicide

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Gaurrich

Name

Robert Gaurrich

Age

Cause of Death

Gunshot

Info

Gunshot

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Pensyl

Name

Caralee Pensyl

Age

Cause of Death

Homicide

Info

The victim’s nude, decomposed body was found

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Kupryczuk

Name

Walter Kupryczuk

Age

33

Cause of Death

Gunshot

Info

Gunshot wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Solt

Name

Barbara Solt

Age

27

Cause of Death

Murdered

Info

Murdered

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Miller

Name

Sandra Miller

Age

Cause of Death

Stabb

Info

Stab wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Green

Name

Timothy Green

Age

62

Cause of Death

Missing

Info

Missing

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Groomes

Name

Ada Groomes

Age

54

Cause of Death

Homicide

Info

Homicide

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Comer

Name

William Comer

Age

Cause of Death

Stabb

Info

Stab wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Krenzel

Name

Louisa Krenzel

Age

Cause of Death

Gunshot

Info

Gunshot wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Dean

Name

Thomas Dean

Age

Cause of Death

Stabb

Info

His motorcycle was intentionally struck by a dark green large square shaped suv displaying a yellow license plate. thomas lawrence dean was killed as a result of injuries sustained from the crash of his motorcycle

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Bodenschatz

Name

Beth Bodenschatz

Age

Cause of Death

Gunshot

Info

Gunshot wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Kachonik

Name

Steven Kachonik

Age

Cause of Death

Gunshot

Info

Gunshot wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Mitchell

Name

Harry Mitchell

Age

Cause of Death

Gunshot

Info

Gunshot wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Copper

Name

Albert Copper

Age

34

Cause of Death

Missing

Info

Missing

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Kerstetter

Name

Dale Kerstetter

Age

52

Cause of Death

Missing

Info

Missing

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Miller

Name

Denise Miller

Age

20

Cause of Death

Stabb

Info

Stab wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Meray

Name

Gregory Meray

Age

Cause of Death

Strangulation

Info

Gregory meray died because of asphyxia due to carbon monoxide poisoning, the fire was determined to be intentionally set and gregory meray’s death was ruled a homicide

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Fosnaught

Name

Scott Fosnaught

Age

15

Cause of Death

Stabb

Info

Had been struck by a vehicle(s)

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Baur

Name

Shawn Baur

Age

15

Cause of Death

Stabb

Info

Had been struck by a vehicle(s)

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Harvat

Name

John Harvat

Age

Cause of Death

Gunshot

Info

Gunshot wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__West

Name

Marjorie West

Age

4

Cause of Death

Missing

Info

Missing

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__James

Name

Billy James

Age

Cause of Death

Gunshot

Info

Gunshot wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Auteri

Name

Michael Auteri

Age

Cause of Death

Missing

Info

Missing

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Goldman

Name

Jean Goldman

Age

Cause of Death

Gunshot

Info

Gunshot wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Carbaugh

Name

Emerson Carbaugh

Age

64

Cause of Death

Missing

Info

Missing

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Pierson

Name

Denise Pierson

Age

18

Cause of Death

Murdered

Info

Murdered

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Kane

Name

Anna Kane

Age

26

Cause of Death

Strangulation

Info

Strangulation

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Witt

Name

Joline Witt

Age

Cause of Death

Homicide

Info

A forensic pathologist determined the cause of death to be violent homicide

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Esh

Name

Orie Esh

Age

Cause of Death

Murdered

Info

The unknown suspect(s) burned the victim’s residence while he was inside, causing his death

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Sharkey

Name

William Sharkey

Age

49

Cause of Death

Gunshot

Info

The victim’s body was severely burned and had been shot to death

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Wiggins

Name

Debra Wiggins

Age

31

Cause of Death

Murdered

Info

Murdered

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Redner

Name

Gary Redner

Age

55

Cause of Death

Stabb

Info

Stab wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Wimbish

Name

Richard Wimbish

Age

49

Cause of Death

Gunshot

Info

Gunshot wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Lloyd Sr

Name

James Lloyd Sr

Age

65

Cause of Death

Gunshot

Info

Gunshot wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__McBride

Name

Kelly McBride

Age

22

Cause of Death

Homicide

Info

Homicide

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Kemp

Name

Ryan Kemp

Age

30

Cause of Death

Missing

Info

Missing

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Gross

Name

David Gross

Age

21

Cause of Death

Strangulation

Info

Strangulation

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Schultz

Name

Gail Schultz

Age

18

Cause of Death

Stabb

Info

Stab wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Schultz

Name

Paul Schultz

Age

12

Cause of Death

Stabb

Info

Stab wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Kiefer

Name

Frances Kiefer

Age

44

Cause of Death

Missing

Info

Missing

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Hnath

Name

Rose Hnath

Age

Cause of Death

Stabb

Info

Stab wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Brantweiner

Name

Sharon Brantweiner

Age

19

Cause of Death

Strangulation

Info

Strangulation

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Mitchell

Name

John Mitchell

Age

58

Cause of Death

Missing

Info

Missing

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Bealer

Name

John Bealer

Age

50

Cause of Death

Missing

Info

Missing

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Freeman Sr

Name

Robert Freeman Sr

Age

Cause of Death

Stabb

Info

Stab wound

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Pyles

Name

Eric Pyles

Age

12

Cause of Death

Missing

Info

Missing

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right

cold-case-record__Horwith

Name

Jeffrey Horwith

Age

Cause of Death

Murdered

Info

Murdered

Agency

Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers

View Source Square with arrow pointing upper right